Current:Home > StocksKat Von D wins lawsuit over Miles Davis tattoo, says her 'heart has been crushed' by trial -Elevate Capital Network
Kat Von D wins lawsuit over Miles Davis tattoo, says her 'heart has been crushed' by trial
View
Date:2025-04-15 20:34:11
LOS ANGELES — Celebrity tattoo artist Kat Von D did not violate a photographer's copyright when she used his portrait of Miles Davis as the basis for a tattoo she'd inked on a friend's arm, a jury decided Jan. 26.
The Los Angeles jury deliberated for just over two hours before deciding that the tattoo by the "Miami Ink" and "LA Ink" alum — born Katherine von Drachenberg — was not similar enough to photographer Jeffrey Sedlik's 1989 portrait of the jazz legend that she needed to have paid permission.
"I'm obviously very happy for this to be over," Von D, who inked her friend's arm with Davis as a gift about seven years ago, said outside the courtroom. "It's been two years of a nightmare worrying about this, not just for myself but for my fellow tattoo artists."
Von D also said that despite the victory, she's not enthused about getting back to work.
"I think I don't want to ever tattoo again; my heart has been crushed through this in different ways," she said. "We'll see with time."
Kat Von D's lawyer calls copyright lawsuit 'ridiculous'
The eight jurors made the same decision about a drawing Von D made from the portrait to base the tattoo on, and to several social media posts she made about the process, which were also part of Sedlik's lawsuit.
And they found that the tattoo, drawing and posts also all fell within the legal doctrine of fair use of a copyrighted work, giving Von D and other tattoo artists who supported her and followed the trial a resounding across-the-board victory.
"We've said all along that this case never should have been brought," Von D's attorney Allen B. Grodsky said after the verdict. "The jury recognized that this was just ridiculous."
Sedlik's attorney, Robert Edward Allen, said they plan to appeal.
Why photographer Jeffrey Sedlik sued Kat Von D: 'No one's art is safe'
Allen said the images, which both featured a close-up of Davis gazing toward the viewer and making a "shh" gesture, were so similar he didn't know how the jury could reach the conclusion they did.
"If those two things are not substantially similar, then no one's art is safe," Allen said.
He told jurors during closing arguments earlier Friday that the case has "nothing to do with tattoos."
"It's about copying others' protected works," Allen said. "It's not going to hurt the tattoo industry. The tattoo police are not going to come after anyone."
Allen emphasized the meticulous work Sedlik did to set up the shoot, to create the lighting and mood, and to put Davis in the pose that would make for an iconic photo that was first published on the cover of JAZZIZ magazine in 1989. Sedlik registered the copyright in 1994.
And he said that subsequently, licensing the image to others including tattoo artists was a major part of how he made his living.
Kat Von D finds spiritual rebirth:Watch her get baptized after giving up witchcraft practice
Kat Von D says her tattoos are a form of 'fan art'
Von D said during the three-day trial that she never licenses the images she recreates, and she considers work like the Davis tattoo a form of "fan art."
"I made zero money off it," she testified. "I'm not mass-producing anything. I think there is a big difference."
Her attorney, Grodsky, emphasized for jurors that that lack of an attempt to cash in on the image was essential to the tattoo being a form of fair use, an exception in copyright law used for works including commentary, criticism and parody.
Allen argued in his closing that the social media posts about the tattoo were a promotion of her and her studio, and thus a form of monetizing the image.
If jurors had sided with Sedlik, they could have awarded him as little as a few hundred dollars or as much as $150,000.
veryGood! (36)
Related
- 'Malcolm in the Middle’ to return with new episodes featuring Frankie Muniz
- 2% of kids and 7% of adults have gotten the new COVID shots, US data show
- Farmington police release video from fatal shooting of armed man on Navajo reservation
- Snow piles up in North Dakota as region’s first major snowstorm of the season moves eastward
- 'Most Whopper
- Maine mass shooting victims: What to know about the 18 people who died
- Residents shelter in place as manhunt intensifies following Lewiston, Maine, mass shooting
- Abortions in the U.S. rose slightly after states began imposing bans and restrictions post-Roe, study finds
- Angelina Jolie nearly fainted making Maria Callas movie: 'My body wasn’t strong enough'
- Week 9 college football expert picks: Top 25 game predictions led by Oregon-Utah
Ranking
- Chuck Scarborough signs off: Hoda Kotb, Al Roker tribute legendary New York anchor
- Exiled Russian journalist discusses new book, alleged poisoning attempt
- Week 9 college football expert picks: Top 25 game predictions led by Oregon-Utah
- Inflation is driving up gift prices. Here's how to avoid overspending this holiday.
- Breaking debut in Olympics raises question: Are breakers artists or athletes?
- Hilary Duff Proves Daughter Banks Is Her Mini-Me in 5th Birthday Tribute
- 'Naked Attraction' offers low-hanging fruit
- Best Buy recalls almost 1 million pressure cookers after spewed contents burn 17 people
Recommendation
Justice Department, Louisville reach deal after probe prompted by Breonna Taylor killing
Amid massive search for mass killing suspect, Maine residents remain behind locked doors
Jonathan Majors' ex-girlfriend arrested amid domestic violence case against the actor
Maine shooting survivor says he ran down bowling alley and hid behind pins to escape gunman: I just booked it
DoorDash steps up driver ID checks after traffic safety complaints
Britney Spears' Ex Sam Asghari Reacts to Her Memoir Revelation About Their Marriage
The White House and Google launch a new virtual tour with audio captions, Spanish translation
Rays push for swift approval of financing deal for new Tampa Bay ballpark, part of $6B development